The idea with tests is that people should left their test results only on new tracker and not in the comments. Now we have some kind of transition time when people get used to it. And parsing of comments is not the best option for me personally.

I guess we have to adjust to the new workflow

I'd also like to keep us from parsing the comments.

What we could do is displaying the test results form JTracker in GitHub, if this is usefull?

What we could do is displaying the test results form JTracker in GitHub, if this is usefull?

I think that this definitely will be useful, but how to display them? Using some special label? ;)

I am thinking since some time about a special "Jtracker comment" that might hold all information not present on GitHub (Travis and Scrutinizer results, user test results, maybe checkstyle errors, etc.).
This comment would be updated whenever the information on JTracker changes.

Using a label would be another option..

@b2z I would like this as a one line signature
E.g. we can use the joomla logo with the text JTracker
And then have an anchored text only the number of the issue in your example: issue: 510
Then another text easy: and then octoicon F03A (ok) or F081 (x)
Then text Tests: 0:octoicon F03A 0: F081 (x)

here are some of the available icons:


This comment was created with the J!Tracker Application at issues.joomla.org/jtracker/510.

@dgt41 do you mean one line comment? BTW feel free to discuss it in #520

I'd like to use octicons since we also have them available on issues.joomla.org.
But how could we display them, using markdown, both on our site and on GitHub?

For sure we can use emoticons, here is the full list
http://www.emoji-cheat-sheet.com

Testing:

Easy: or || Tests: Passing: 0 Failing: 0

Easy: :heavy_plus_sign: or :heavy_minus_sign: Tests: Passing: 0 :ballot_box_with_check: Failing: 0 :heavy_multiplication_x:

Great idea I totally emojis - (we should support auto complete in JTracker )

Currently this file is in @elkuku's repo (blame PHPStorm...) written in mustache.
https://github.com/elkuku/jissues/blob/github-status-comment/src/App/Tracker/tpl/github-status-comment.mustache
Fell free to modify and send a PR

Great idea I totally emojis - (we should support auto complete in JTracker )

@elkuku https://github.com/ichord/At.js

Somehow I've starred this project months ago and I think this could help:)

https://github.com/ichord/At.js

Totally it - Thanks for sharing!

It's been awhile since there was any comment on this, so here I go. @dgt41 pointed this thread out to me because I am having quite some trouble recognizing test results in the issues. I have to scan all the comments to make sure there are enough tests. People who comment via GitHub will never use our Test result module.

Coming up with something that could help us out would be nice. I do agree with @b2z that parsing text is not ideal. We could get false test results. This issue can probably be closed and continued in #520.

Closed in favor of #520