I have tested this item ✅ successfully on b38b05d

I have tested this item ✅ successfully on 224214d

Is the menu text not a bit imprecise. We have "Save & Close" what does what it says, but the "Save to Menu as List" is more Save & Close & Add List Menu Item. I know it is a bit long but maybe someoen else has a better idea. And yes I know it is the same for article.

@rdeutz Beyond the scope of this pr for the reasons you stated. If German needs to be - more explicit then it can be done in the translation.

I think @rdeutz point of view is important. It is not so much about the language as about the logic of expression. Moreover, we must realize that English is not only English, but also the base language from which other languages ​​are based.

if I am to understand this feature, then I understand it in the case of:

Save & Close & Add List Menu Item

but I have no idea what it is about in the case of:

Save to Menu as List

And please take this as my personal opinion, I understand it as some kind of moving the article to some other group.

@rdeutz A completely different idea might even be to open it in a dialog. I find this sudden context switch somehow confusing. But maybe it's just me. But this is really out of scope of this PR. ?

@LadySolveig I was confused too, so we are two :-)

It is still out of scope of this PR as it is NOT a new behaviour. In fact Save to menu was added 5 years ago as a result of a survey in the german community to replace an existing toolbar button called new menu item

It is still out of scope of this PR as it is NOT a new behaviour. In fact Save to menu was added 5 years ago as a result of a survey in the german community to replace an existing toolbar button called new menu item

Thanks for the explanation, I understand now, sorry, my ignorance of this feature.

I have tested this item ✅ successfully on 224214d

I have tested this successfully.

This has three successful tests - what do I need to do to get the status changed to RTC?

RTC

You might just want to give us some time. I do have an eye on this PR. But please also keep in mind that right now if we follow our own rules, we can basically only merge about one PR per hour and I'm not working on Joomla 24/7, so it might take a day or two to process this.

i was not chasing a merge just RTC so that others didnt waste their time on this one and tested something else

Thank you for your contribution @brianteeman! For now this is okay like this, in a future PR I would like to see this not restricted to just com_content, but to extend this to other components as well and make it a bit more flexible.

Thank you for your contribution @brianteeman! For now this is okay like this, in a future PR I would like to see this not restricted to just com_content, but to extend this to other components as well and make it a bit more flexible.

Thanks @Hackwar

It is not restricted to com_content as such it is just specific to com_content. It can be added to the two other core components that have a category view (newsfeeds and contacts) where it is even simpler as they only have a list view. I can submit a new PR if you wish for those components

I'd like to have a mechanism which allows also third party extensions which use com_categories to also use this.

I'd like to have a mechanism which allows also third party extensions which use com_categories to also use this.

Ah sorry - I misunderstood you. I think that's an easy fix to do - I will look at it once this has been merged