Feeling Lucky
No Code Attached Yet
[#43104] - SEF links in J4 different from J3 (in J3 the SEF is correct)
- Closed
- 22 Mar 2024
- Medium
- Build: 4.4.3
- # 43104
Steps to reproduce the issue
J3.10.12 and 4.4.3
- Search Engine Friendly URLs: Yes
- Use URL Rewriting: Yes
- Articles with keyword(s)
- Publish e.g. module Articles - Related
- Display the same article in J3 and J4.
- Look at the links in module Articles - Related
Expected result
- SEF-Links in J3 and J4 are equal e.g.:
- https://(domain)/186-uitslagen-2008-2017/buurcontactommelander-loopcircuit-200817/845-eemsmondloop-Uithuizermeeden-10-en-5-km-18-september-2010
Actual result
- SEF-Links in J3 and J4 are different. In J4 no SEF is visible.
- J3: https://(domain)/186-uitslagen-2008-2017/buurcontactommelander-loopcircuit-200817/845-eemsmondloop-Uithuizermeeden-10-en-5-km-18-september-2010
- J4: https://(domain)/?view=article&id=845:eemsmondloop-Uithuizermeeden-10-en-5-km-18-september-2010&catid=186
System information (as much as possible)
J3.10.12 and 4.4.3
- Search Engine Friendly URLs: Yes
- Use URL Rewriting: Yes
- Articles with keyword(s)
Additional comments
- It happens with converted articles (from J3 --> J4) as well as new articles
- The articles are not linked to a menu item.
Votes
# of Users Experiencing Issue
1/1
Average Importance Score
3.00
| Labels |
Removed:
?
|
||
joomla-cms-bot
- | Labels |
Added:
No Code Attached Yet
|
||
| Status | New | ⇒ | Closed |
| Closed_Date | 0000-00-00 00:00:00 | ⇒ | 2024-03-22 20:59:49 |
| Closed_By | ⇒ | Hackwar |
peterhulst
- comment
- 23 Mar 2024
Thanks you for your answer. Although it is expected behaviour, it does not explain the difference between J3 (with nice URLs) an J4 (with ugly URLs). Has the router in J4 changed that much and why? The menu structure is not changed between my J3 an J4 version.
The last line in your description is what is the main point in this. This is not a bug, but actually expected behavior. At least more or less. Yes, we would want to have a URL without query parameters, but that is already tackled by #42989. But besides that, this is intended behavior and you would have to create the right menu structure for your site to work in such a manner.