can you do a PR against staging-Branch like @brianteeman suggested at #16973 (comment)?

how?

@mundogame You conding this on Github or locally?

From a search i found https://docs.joomla.org/Working_with_git_and_github, which looks like a starting Point. Maybe other knows better Sources – if so, please write here, thanks.

If i make a pull request, only see the compare branches text, and need to choose two to continue. Can be a bad configuration in the joomla github

@mundogame I don't see joomla-cms repo fork on https://github.com/mundogame?tab=repositories - fork this repo or make fork public.

@mundogame See https://docs.joomla.org/Using_the_Github_UI_to_Make_Pull_Requests. You cen edit many files in one PR (Pull_Request).

Why would this be put into core rather than someone just making an extension?

If someone making a extension, only that extension can benefit of this feature. If a badge system can be integrated in joomla, many modules and components around the world can make adjustments to implement the feature.

For example a forum component, can add this to the profiles of the users, or a store component can add this to incentivate purchases or virtual prices. The possibilities are endless!

There are already extensions for this, having used some of them in the past. Alpha User Points. Not sure if it's still maintained, but if I rightly remember, someone has forked it.

Alpha User Points dont use a badge system, and dont have gamification mechanics. The original developer of AUP abandoned the project.

I give you another 2 examples:

• A news module or component give badges for an user, when this user read news. The badges can be personalized for types. For example if this user read many sport news, a badge can show this in the joomla profile. The user have a visual price, the webmaster know what are the prefered news of this user.

• Another example can be an advancement. The sports user win the badge of Sports level 2. With this badge unlocked, can win a Special coupon in the store with discounts. And in the Store another badge spawn for the first purchase.

We need to add more beauty for the User Profiles in joomla, and make them more modern and efficient, and a Badge System, can help to achieve this. Another systems same Mango, Drupal or Wordpress have similar things, but joomla not.

As much as I like the idea, this should be done as a 3PE, not part of core. This would benefit sites that are used for things such as gaming communities, etc, but other than that, I can't see this being beneficial as part of the core in the slightest.

this should be done as a 3PE, not part of core

Agree.

Not every Joomla site uses Users, or User Profiles

Community Builder and others have led the way with this in the past...

Closed as this is for an extension not the core