[#36074] - Ldap auntification not work
- Closed
- 20 Jun 2022
- Medium
- Build: 4.0-dev
- # 36074
Steps to reproduce the issue
activated and configured the plugin as in version 3
Expected result
passing authorization
Actual result
The username or password was entered incorrectly, or such an account does not exist.
System information (as much as possible)
{"host":"10.2.1.3","port":389,"use_ldapV3":1,"negotiate_tls":0,"ignore_reqcert_tls":0,"no_referrals":0,"auth_method":"search","base_dn":"dc=itgroup,dc=local","search_string":"sAMAccountName=[search]","users_dn":"","username":"ldap@i.local","password":"AhqM5","ldap_fullname":"displayName","ldap_email":"mail","ldap_uid":"uid","ldap_debug":0}
Additional comments
plugin settings are made in the same way as for version 3. Websites work on one server
joomla-cms-bot
- | Labels |
Added:
No Code Attached Yet
|
||
@HLeithner there are a LOT of open issues that the ldap plugin does not work in j4
I would expect that it should work better then in j3...
I would expect the total opposite. LDAP support in Joomla 4 is broken, unusable and requires a complete rewrite with input from real world users that use LDAP along with its myriad of configurations, with and without SSL/TLS.
so, then it's good that we switched... still can't fix it because I don't have a setup for this, the last time I fixed a security issue in our ldap package took me a long time to build a working setup... if someone can help out It would be very appreciated .
I'm in bed but if you search github you will find my very documented set up of ldap in a docker container
but the problem with that is that in the real world there are a million different configurations - this is why it's best tackled by someone with in-depth access and experience with live ldap servers
I tried my best before but a lot has changed and right now it's all pretty much broken
See #35216 (comment)
that's exactly the problem, running a documented container form the internet doesn't solve anything you have to understand ldap... I tried and hated it and gave up... (after the fix^^)
the alternative could be to switch pack to the joomla-framework v1 version... (I know not the best solution)
| Status | New | ⇒ | Closed |
| Closed_Date | 0000-00-00 00:00:00 | ⇒ | 2022-06-20 22:38:46 |
| Closed_By | ⇒ | richard67 |
I hope this is not your real password, if it is you should change it.
Sadly I have no ldap implementation to test, but since we use the symfony package in j4 I would expect that it should work better then in j3...