Looks about right to me

I have tested this item 🔴 unsuccessfully on 90a67ec

after creating art2 the star is missed on art1 article Item Version History

did you fix the database ?

No, will retest (Fix Database after "apply Patch"?)

yes, sorry for uncomplete test info

Updated Instructions.

I have tested this item ✅ successfully on 90a67ec

Before applying the Patch, I made following tests:
Created an article & saved (art1)
Some changes in that article (art1)
Created another article (art2) etc.

Actual result

after creating of art2 the star was not missed on art1 article Item Version History.
You can keep it as current version. Or to activate (select) required version for restoring (star).

@ChristineWk please mark your test as successfully > https://docs.joomla.org/Testing_Joomla!_patches#Recording_test_results

@franz-wohlkoenig: I didn't use the Patch. My "Actual result" was without applying the Patch.

I have tested (patch applied via patchtester on a 3.9.5 installation).
Before patch, the issue is as described.
After applying the patch and fixing the database - same issue as before, no star is displayed in versions of article1.

So it was not successful for me.

@chmst please mark your test as unsuccessfully > https://docs.joomla.org/Testing_Joomla!_patches#Recording_test_results

I have tested this item 🔴 unsuccessfully on c655a92

I have tested this item 🔴 unsuccessfully on c655a92

I have tested this item 🔴 unsuccessfully on c655a92

I followed exactly the instructions here and there (#9287) and also fixed the database.

Result: Always 2 version entries for "Article 1" but no star before and after patch.

@chmst & @ReLater: Thanks for testing. Sorry, maybe I made some steps too much before patch.

I have tested this item 🔴 unsuccessfully on c655a92

Create an article & save (art1) > here was my failure (in previous test): I saved & closed & reopened
Do some changes in that article (art1)
Create another article (art2)

Tested again now - Before Patch: Result: no star in versions of article 1.

After applying the patch and fixing the database - same as above: Test unsuccessfully.

Edit: Sorry, I don't know, why I have h2 above instead of p

I have tested this item 🔴 unsuccessfully on c655a92

Create an article & save (art1) > here was my failure (in previous test): I saved & closed & reopened
Do some changes in that article (art1)
Create another article (art2)

Tested again now - Before Patch: Result: no star in versions of article 1.

After applying the patch and fixing the database - same as above: Test unsuccessfully.

that's weird if I run the same query in this patch via phpmyadmin administrator/components/com_admin/sql/updates/postgresql/3.9.7-2019-04-26.sql i got the correct result

i.e ignoreChanges":["modified_by", "modified", "checked_out", "checked_out_time", "version", "hits", "ordering"]
viceversa

if I run via database fix got wrong result as you reported

i.e ignoreChanges":["modified_by", "modified", "checked_out", "checked_out_time", "version", "hits"]
without "ordering"

need some more investigation... sorry

@alikon As i tested first Time got unsuccessfully Result, 2nd time got successfully Test so i thought i had Mistakes in 1st run.

that's weird if I run the same query in this patch via phpmyadmin administrator/components/com_admin/sql/updates/postgresql/3.9.7-2019-04-26.sql i got the correct result

Confirmed. The same with https://github.com/alikon/joomla-cms/blob/patch-92/administrator/components/com_admin/sql/updates/mysql/3.9.7-2019-04-26.sql . It works via phpMyAdmin.

Ok so that is the situation:
The Database Fix (com_installer) only work for DDL and not with DML (ie don't run UPDATE)
instead
The Joomla update (com_joomlaupdate) run both DDL and DML

so the easy way to test is to run the query via phpmyadmin

I have tested this item ✅ successfully on c655a92

1. test via phpMyAdmin
2. test via installation of https://github.com/alikon/joomla-cms/archive/patch-92.zip

@alikon

The Database Fix (com_installer) only work for DDL and not with DML (ie don't run UPDATE)

Isn't that a new issue in Joomla 3? Because the database fix runs without any messages but didn't do its job and says "database Ok" afterwards.

I have tested this item ✅ successfully on c655a92

Test via phpMyAdmin

@ReLater some kind of messages is displayed after all

1 database changes did not alter table structure and were skipped.

so maybe something should be addressed in 4.x

thanks for testing folks

RTC

thanks for testing folks

RTC

1 database changes did not alter table structure and were skipped.

Ah, "structure" is the magic difference. Nice to know. I've overlooked that since ever. I've always messages like that when I fix a database and always thought "everything's OK now".
Thus when one updates a crashed website via FTP and uses the fix button which is (maybe) not sufficient one should recommend a final Joomla Update > Upload & Update.

Merged, thanks!