Hi,

I tested and wasn't able to reproduce on default Joomla install. My best guess it has something to do with Kunena, which we shouldn't be worried about.

Thanks,
Chetan

Its a joomla issue.
Please create a Menu Item Alias on mainmenu, then you will see the issue.

Hello,

My bad, I thought you said Kunena so it must have something to do with Kunena. I'll check again.

It's working just fine. Can't reproduce this.

looks like a local issue then.

Reopen please. I can reproduce this issue. It was introduced with #24416, specifically this part https://github.com/joomla/joomla-cms/pull/24416/files#diff-94f7ebd2e6d116a7e0e4e66ae94f5e06R173.

@chetanmadaan please use the latest nightly.

@alikon

I can reproduce when creating a Menu Item Alias or system links in general, not any other it seems.

confirm, but weird

I can apparently solve it here by modifying the model
/administrator/components/com_menus/Model/ItemsModel.php line 277 +
from

		$query->select(
			'CASE ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('component') . ' THEN a.published+2*(e.enabled-1) ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('url') . ' AND a.published != -2 THEN a.published+2 ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('url') . ' AND a.published = -2 THEN a.published-1 ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('alias') . ' AND a.published != -2 THEN a.published+4 ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('alias') . ' AND a.published = -2 THEN a.published-1 ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('separator') . ' AND a.published != -2 THEN a.published+6 ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('separator') . ' AND a.published = -2 THEN a.published-1 ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('heading') . ' AND a.published != -2 THEN a.published+8 ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('heading') . ' AND a.published = -2 THEN a.published-1 ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('container') . ' AND a.published != -2 THEN a.published+8 ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('container') . ' AND a.published = -2 THEN a.published-1 ' .
			' END AS published '
		);

to

		$query->select(
			'CASE ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('component') . ' THEN a.published+2*(e.enabled-1) ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('url') . '  THEN a.published ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('alias') . '  THEN a.published ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('separator') . '  THEN a.published ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('heading') . '  THEN a.published ' .
				' WHEN a.type = ' . $db->quote('container') . '  THEN a.published ' .
			' END AS published '
		);

Since 1.7 we were using the MenusHtmlMenus state() method to display the state on the grid.
It considered the $enabled status of the component and displayed a tip

Therefore not sure of the code above for the component as the helper method is not present anymore in 4.0

Note:
if we do not need anymore $enabled for the component, we could simplify the whole query select by taking off the CASE, simply using:

		$query->select(
			$this->getState(
				'list.select',
				$db->quoteName(
					array(
						'a.id', 'a.menutype', 'a.title', 'a.alias', 'a.note', 'a.path', 'a.link', 'a.type', 'a.parent_id',
						'a.level', 'a.published', 'a.component_id', 'a.checked_out', 'a.checked_out_time', 'a.browserNav',
						'a.access', 'a.img', 'a.template_style_id', 'a.params', 'a.lft', 'a.rgt', 'a.home', 'a.language',
						'a.client_id', 'a.publish_up', 'a.publish_down'
					)
				)
			)
		);

What do you think?

Just found out we still have the state() method in Service/HTML/Menus.php.
Shall we keep the method or just delete it too?

With former code we do get a tip, although wrongly displayed

Please test #25185
closing this issue

Please test this new one
#25197